The Appearance of Perfection (Dennis Aubrey)


Via Lucis is a photography blog but we also do a lot of writing. We are not trying to preach, but to provide context for our photography of the Romanesque and Gothic churches. PJ’s take is “I’m trying to capture the architecture, the play of light on stone, and the beauty of the church. I try to find a way to express the spirit of the church. Sometimes I’m just moved by the shapes and the patterns.”

For myself, I’m trying to understand those forces that moved the people who built the churches and to explore the genius of the builders. This post is another examination of that genius. In this case, we are talking about using imperfections to give the appearance of perfection.

Entasis was primarily used on massive structures (like the Parthenon) that are meant to be viewed from rather large distances and corrects for parallax distortion. As the distance increases, a phenomenon occurs that makes parallel lines (such as the sides of columns) appear to narrow in the middle.

Hering illusion

Hering illusion

The phenomenon of entasis is well known and documented. The Parthenon is famous for it. I still remember my first realization that the Greeks distorted the perfection of their columns so that they would appear to be perfect – to me this was the very definition of genius. But the Greeks did not invent this concept – like their mathematics, they borrowed it from the Egyptians. From the Egyptians even more than the Greeks we understand that entasis was less corrective of an optical distortion than an aesthetic correction.

In Egypt, these visual compensations were used a thousand years before the Parthenon – the statue of Ramses at Luxor has an example of a compensation with the exaggerated smile of Ramses.

Photo from Dunn, Advanced Engineering in the Temples of the Pharaohs

Photo from Dunn, Advanced Engineering in the Temples of the Pharaohs

Christopher Dunn points out in his Lost Technologies of Ancient Egypt: Advanced Engineering in the Temples of the Pharaohs that only the mouth is smiling; the rest of the face is at rest. But he identifies the reason for this exaggeration – the smile only appears exaggerated when we view the head from the the same elevation. When viewed from the ground level far below, the smile is more natural. Without the exaggeration, the mouth would appear to scowl.

Less well known is that entasis and these visual distortions were used by medieval builders in their churches and cathedrals. For years it was mistakenly believed that these imperfections existed because the builders thought that only God was perfect and so the church could not be so. This misunderstanding carried over into modern times. The builders of Washington National Cathedral added several “imperfections” for this very reason.

There are other fanciful notions to explain medieval construction anomalies. There is a well-known phenomenon in medieval churches that the apse is often slightly off-center to the line of the nave.

Floorplan of Basilique Sainte Madeleine, Vézelay (From Dehio and von Bezoid "Die Kirchliche Baukunst des abendlandes" 1887-1902 - Image in the public domain)

The romantic notion was that this reflected the passion of Christ, whose head fell to one side during the crucifixion. In reality, it seems to be a form of entasis. By adjusting the sight line to the columns of the hemicycle, we see the spaces more clearly and the columns don’t seem to run together.

The more realistic understanding of medieval distortions was propounded in the United States by William Henry Goodyear in a series of influential lectures in 1915. He proposed that the irregularities and asymmetries in medieval buildings were not errors but were carefully planned in the structures.

“The extreme subtlety and extraordinary constructive skill and forethought that are found in these arrangements, when considered with their inconspicuous and generally unobtrusive character,  justify us in applying the term ‘architectural refinements’ to them.”   William Henry Goodyear, Illustrated Catalog of Photographs and Surveys of Architectural Refinements in Medieval Buildings

These photographs from Goodyear’s Illustrated Catalogue Of Photographs & Surveys Of Architectural Refinements In Medieval Buildings (Edinburgh 1905) illustrate some of the remarkable refinements created by medieval builders.

In the Cathédrale Notre Dame d’Amiens, the soaring nave features a spreading of the nave columns outward to compensate for the vertical perspective convergence when seen from below. Notice how the upper portions of the nave columns actually start to lean outwards. “The measures establish the fact that the inclinations are practically uniform throughout the nave and choir, although the wall measures average a little less than those of the piers … The constructive strain is entirely carried by the piers, and their leans are the ones to be considered, especially as the entire inclinations, from pavement to vaulting, are related to these measures for the piers.”

Goodyear also states, “It appears probable that the diverging piers at the crossing of Notre-Dame [de Paris] were noticed by Viollet-le-Duc, but that the true amount of the divergence was not apprehended by him, just as the divergence at Amiens escaped his notice entirely.” This fact demonstrates that the purpose of the refinement was remain invisible to the eye.

Screen shot Amiens nave

The refinements can also be in plan form instead of vertical. Here we see the concavity of the facade of Saint Mark’s Cathedral in Venice. According to Goodyear, “The south transept south gallery parapet has a curve in plan convex to the interior, which has the optical and perspective effect of a curve in elevation.”

Screen shot Saint Mark's facade

In this shot of the vaulting shafts of the transepts at Notre Dame de Paris, note the existence of the two plumb lines that surround the column to the right. These are hanging vertical and show clearly the lean of the column carrying the vault. Goodyear notes that this column is parallel to its twin on the left. He states that “the columns in the north transept galleries lean north, and that all the columns in the south transept galleries lean south. The possibility that the columnar leans are due to careless setting is thus outside the range of probabilities.”

Screen shot Paris transept

The Église Saint Aignan in Saint Quentin is rich in these refinements. In the next shot we clearly see the vertical compensations to correct for perspective distortion.

Screen shot Saint Quentin vertical curves

In the closeup, we can actually see where the compensations begin high upon the nave columns. This documentation by Goodyear is essential in understanding how these refinements were meant to work.

Screen shot Saint Quentin vertical pier

The fact that the medieval builders could design and execute such subtle refinements without benefit of pre-visualization computers and modeling is amazing to us. How did they plan and execute these adjustments which correct for human vision from distance? We don’t have records from there, but there is evidence from Hellenistic times that may be instructive. At the temple of Apollo at Didyma in Turkey, a mason’s drawing was found etched in the temple wall a few years ago that describes how the mason was to carve a column with the proper curvature.

Capture

PJ and I will be shooting the Église Saint Aignan in Saint Quentin this spring. One of my main objectives will be to photograph those deformations. However, with all of the perspective distortions involved with photographing these structures (including those introduced by the camera and the tilt-shift lenses), there are huge technical challenges to accomplishing anything meaningful. This is one reason we are so pleased to have the opportunity to prepare by shooting at the Bryn Athyn Cathedral in December. In this way, the architecture of the church leads us to develop techniques for photography. And these techniques, in turn, allow us to discover more about these sublime imperfections and the intent of the original medieval builders.

Note: I would like to thank my beloved niece, Aubrey Elizabeth Hanson, for finding me a copy of the Didyma drawing. She was trained in classics at Loyala Marymount and just completed her graduate work in Museum Studies at Johns Hopkins University. If anyone wants a bright and willing employee in this field, she’s your candidate!

12 responses to “The Appearance of Perfection (Dennis Aubrey)

  1. Excellent post Dennis! It’s wonderful reading about all these architectural “fixes”. I’ve always disliked the notion that Gothic architects made errors or included some “theological sabotage” in their structures. If one is capable of understanding the structural engineering aspects of building cathedrals, then why not the visual continuity as well?

    While your upcoming trips with focus on capturing entasis, have you ever observed this or other visual distortions during your travels? I feel like you’ve spent so much time deeply observing cathedrals with your photography that this subtly may have popped up in the past.

    Best of luck with the Bryn Athyn Cathedral and the Église Saint Aignan. Looking forward to your images!

    • Christina, so nice to hear from you on this. Agree with you on the arrogance of the modern critics. These medieval architects were using warped surfaces to strengthen their vaults for centuries before modern architects even grasped the concept. The vault at Reims withstood assaults from modern artillery in World War I!

      As far as the visual distortions, we have seen many. Most of them are in the Gothic churches since the sophistication necessary for these required practice and very large structures, but they occurred in Italy quite early. We have seen many very interesting adjustments, however, that demonstrate the acuity of the builders. Here is one at Vézelay. Look at the section about the hemicycle in this post.

      The practice of Stützenwechsel is demonstrated at Sainte Foy in Conques and many other places – another subtle but effective variation in architectural practice. We are constantly finding these remarkable details in the churches. The difference this time is that I am working on techniques to try to capture some of these architectural variations, which can be quite subtle, especially since they are not meant to be seen – just as Viollet-le-Duc, of all people, who did not perceive the Amiens nave adjustments.

  2. Magnificent Dennis, I am so impressed that you are not just a photographer, or even an “artist” photographer, but such an extremely well informed one. Many years ago I hired a photographer to take images of the Medici-Riccardi palace chapel. He did not do a good job and I did not inform him of the ramifications of why I was asking for images that he had never seen published nor had taken before himself. At that time it was a matter of getting the wall frescoes on film. He offered to redo the chapel, but for reasons I do not know, I said I would take what he had done. Some of them are used in my book being released on Amazon.com this coming week. More importantly, the book includes the results of my measuring the chapel, a trapezoid in plan based on the pre-existing plan of the palace itself on streets at less than right angles to each other. I promise, if I ever have the occasion to hire another photographer, I will insist on educating him of my intentions. I don’t know if it is appropriate to give titles in this Forum format, but it is easy enough to find under my name. By the way, I looked up the district of Lot and your favorite hotel. What a beautiful area and its setting dating so far back in history. Most impressive were the photos of your hotel restaurant desserts. Goodness!
    Darrell

    • Thanks, Darrell, we are certainly passionate about this project which has been our focus for almost a decade now. Our home is filled with books and pictures. One of the greatest things that I have found for research is the Google Book project; rare volumes from the past are digitized and available to read. So many of these were only available in research libraries before.

      As far as your experience with the photographer (I accessed and read your paper, The Iconology of the S. Trinita Sacristy, by the way – JSTOR is great), I guess we’ll see the results when you publish your study on the Medici-Riccardi palace chapel. Make sure to let us know when it is available.

      • Thanks, Dennis, This article is the best I have seen explaining entasis. Excellent research! Thanks for the compliment regarding my 1975 article on the Sacristy of S. Trinita, Florence. It was meant to be followed up with a close examination of Gentile da Fabriano’s Journey and Adoration (Strozzi) altarpiece, but I am just now beginning to complete that long-abandoned effort. In the meantime, I have published the book on the Medici-Riccardi chapel: Title- Secrets of the Medici Palace and Its Private Chapel, now available (2013). There is an inexpensive B&W version and an outrageously priced color version, over which I had very little control. Thanks again for taking the time on the article!

  3. What an informative essay you have posted!
    Your readers would be interested to know that entasis was widely embraced by the master carpenters in the Buddhist civilizations as the technique was gradually introduced through Central Asia. One fine example may be Horyuji Temple in Nara, Japan.

  4. Another wonderful post demonstrating that you and P. J. are not just excellent photographers, but also historians, structural inspectors, and architectural experts. I’m always enthralled with the breadth of expertise demonstrated in your essays.
    I am winding up a eight-week course (one hour per week) entitled “Sacred Sounds in a Sacred Spaces” for Lifequest, an organization that promotes lifetime learning for those 65 years of age and older. I think I mentioned to you in an earlier comment that I developed this program using recorded music and images in my collection to introduce audiences to the evolution of sacred music and architecture in the great churches of medieval Europe.
    I have been asked to develop a new eight-week program on Design and Construction of Medieval Churches for the Lifequest program next year. I’ve agreed to do so, and I think this essay and the drawings that accompany it would make an excellent reading resource for the course. May I have your permission to use it (with attribution, of course)? The Lifequest program offers no compensation to its instructors because they are considered partners in the effort to keep seniors active and alert. Not all of the participants would be interested in a reading like this one, but some would and I’d like to make it available as a handout.
    Jay Fredrich

    • Jay, congratulations on being selected to develop the course! What an interesting subject. Of course you have permission to use any of our published work here on Via Lucis to support your program. We have articles on vaulting that may be of interest as well. Good luck with this.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s